Fantastic Four the Holidays (Holiday Pre-Order)

Reserve your holiday cookies early with our Holiday Pre-Order option. Place your order by November 30th to guarantee your Brown Butter Sea Salt Shortbread Cookies ship during the busy holiday season. Pre-orders will be fulfilled on a first-come, first-served basis and shipped between December 8–19, right in time for gifting and celebrations.

This season, treat yourself (or someone special) to the ultimate cookie collection: Fantastic Four the Holidays! Experience a festive quartet of flavors, each artfully crafted and packaged by the half dozen for easy sharing—or indulging. Each box contains a half dozen (6 cookies) of each of the following flavors:

• Original: Experience the cookie that started it all! What makes our Original flavor so unforgettable is its simplicity. Browned butter, vanilla, and a sprinkle of sea salt create a sweet and salty combination that began in a small deli in Cayucos, California. This is the OG flavor that you should always have stocked in your cookie jar.
• Cocoa: Irresistibly decadent and simply delicious, the Cocoa Brown Butter Sea Salt Shortbread Cookie is an artisanal food lover's dream! The rich yet subtle cocoa floods your taste buds as it simultaneously crumbles and melts with every bite. It's our most popular flavor behind the Original and pairs well with red wine.
• Toffee Chocolate: Savor the exquisite Toffee Chocolate Brown Butter Sea Salt Shortbread Cookie. Velvety brown butter shortbread is loaded with housemade crunchy, chocolate-covered toffee chunks and finished with a sprinkle of sea salt for a decadent, unforgettable treat.
• Spice: Cozy up with our ultimate holiday treat, inspired by classic pumpkin pie. Nutmeg, ginger, cinnamon, and cloves dance together in a rich brown butter dough, creating the quintessential cookie for sweater weather.

Ingredients: Scroll through product images to view ingredient and nutritional information.

Allergy Information: CONTAINS WHEAT, MILK, SOY. Our baking facility uses soy, dairy, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, and eggs on shared equipment.

Cookies are best enjoyed fresh! Ours have a 3 - 4 week shelf life. Enjoy!

Our Brown Butter Sea Salt Shortbread Cookies

Indulge in our Brown Butter Sea Salt Cookies, where classic shortbread meets rich, decadent perfection. We've elevated the timeless shortbread cookie with carefully browned butter, infusing each bite with a depth of flavor that's both comforting and unforgettable. Finished with a delicate sprinkle of sea salt fresh from the oven, these cookies are sealed by the half dozen and presented in our signature gift boxes.